Header Graphic
Dirty-South Blues Harp forum: wail on! > Do I Do harp
Do I Do harp
Login  |  Register
Page: 1

Stevelegh
1 post
Jul 01, 2010
12:33 PM
Hi Everyone,

Is this a blues question? I don't know, but I thought I'd ask it here.

Stevie Wonder's track Do I Do from Original Musiquarium has a chromatic harp solo. I'm trying to figure it out on a C chrom, but I'm beginning to think it's on a G due to the bends in it.

Any thoughts or answers?

Many thanks for reading.

Regards

Stevelegh
nacoran
2312 posts
Jul 01, 2010
1:10 PM
I have no idea. I can't really play chromatic, but I'm sure someone will come along shortly who can. I'll embed a link to the video though. :)



----------
Nate
Facebook
Oisin
590 posts
Jul 01, 2010
4:27 PM
Holy shit...do you check out that trumpet players cheeks when he started to play? Is that for real? happens around 2.27
----------
Oisin
Ryan
315 posts
Jul 01, 2010
10:05 PM
You know that you can bend all the notes on a chromatic right?(except for the top couple holes because they're ussually not valved)
Maybe that's what confusing you.

The bends on a chromatic aren't like bends on a diatonic. The diatonic has double reed bends whereas the chromatic has single reed bends. So since the chromatic harmonica has valves you can bend both the blow and draw notes.

Last Edited by on Jul 01, 2010 10:06 PM
nacoran
2321 posts
Jul 01, 2010
10:43 PM
Oisin, that's Dizzy Gillespie! Actually, I've seen a couple other trumpet greats' cheeks go kind of crazy, but yeah, he's got to be the craziest.

----------
Nate
Facebook
gene
517 posts
Jul 01, 2010
11:07 PM
Ha! The instant I read "Check out that trumpet player's cheeks" I was thinking I'd post a video of Dizzy Gillespie and say, "Oh, yeah? Check this out!"

Then I watched the vid and it IS Dizzy!! :D
Stevelegh
2 posts
Jul 02, 2010
1:41 AM
Hi Ryan,

Yes, you're right in the fact that you can bend pretty much everything on a chrom, but the best way to describe what I mean is by comparing say a 5 draw or a 6 draw on a diatonic. As harp players, we can 'hear' those notes irrespective of key and we know that the 6 draw can really be leant on in the bends. Conversely, a 5 draw has a pretty weak sound and doesn't bend well.

The chrom has certain 'weak' notes and this is where I'm finding the problem. In the first passage of the solo (after the initial flurry of notes with the button) you have 3 notes Bb, B and C#. The C# seems weak when I do it. This may be my technique, but I've learnt harder Stevie pieces, which is making me think I'm using the wrong key of harp.

I hope I make sense.....

Regards

Steve.
Stevelegh
3 posts
Jul 02, 2010
2:01 AM
Dizzy's face is a picture! Damn! You could use cheeks like that for shoplifting!
arzajac
266 posts
Jul 02, 2010
3:11 AM
"I'm trying to figure it out on a C chrom, but I'm beginning to think it's on a G due to the bends in it. "

I think Dizzy Galespie was known for his B-flat 45-degree angle trumpet. Perhaps the song is in B-flat?

----------




Post a Message



(8192 Characters Left)


Modern Blues Harmonica supports

§The Jazz Foundation of America

and

§The Innocence Project

 

 

 

ADAM GUSSOW is an official endorser for HOHNER HARMONICAS