Header Graphic
Dirty-South Blues Harp forum: wail on! > Sharing Harps? !
Sharing Harps? !
Login  |  Register
Page: 1

Littoral
1501 posts
Jul 19, 2017
11:43 AM
Short answer, No. The only exception I recall was for me was Pat Ramsey. This video of Muddy shows Jerry Portnoy handing off one of his harps (at 39:50). What about you?

Last Edited by Littoral on Jul 19, 2017 11:43 AM
Honkin On Bobo
1430 posts
Jul 19, 2017
11:50 AM
Absolutely not. I did once a looong time ago with a drummer friend of mine who wanted to show me a lick. I was reluctant but he's a good guy so I did. I was a little wigged out when he handed it back to me. And I am not even close to being a germaphobe, but I vowed never again and tried to rehearse in my mind what I'd say if anyone asked. So far, no one has. I think I'd reply "Dude, the instrument's kinda personal ya know?" and just walk away.

Last Edited by Honkin On Bobo on Jul 19, 2017 11:54 AM
Littoral
1502 posts
Jul 19, 2017
11:56 AM
"...what I'd say if anyone asked."
How about..."Can I make out with your girlfriend?"
Honkin On Bobo
1431 posts
Jul 19, 2017
12:01 PM
Yup, that would work too.





--------------------------
ejakon
35 posts
Jul 19, 2017
2:21 PM
I only share my harps with Living Gods like Sharpharp, if im lucky, their saliva might transfer their godly skills on the harp to me. though sharpharp hasnt played wet since he bent time on a bflat Blues Harp MS

Last Edited by ejakon on Jul 19, 2017 2:22 PM
tmf714
3082 posts
Jul 19, 2017
2:32 PM
I did with James Cotton!

Looke like Jerry had a new in the box harp in his pocket-look closely.
dougharps
1504 posts
Jul 19, 2017
3:20 PM
If the person asking for your harp is a large intoxicated belligerent biker, go ahead and share!
----------

Doug S.
ME.HarpDoc
260 posts
Jul 19, 2017
4:34 PM
@dougharps
I'd probably say, "You can have this one, I've got more" for the case you described.
jpmcbride
174 posts
Jul 19, 2017
4:58 PM
Generally no. But I've shared a few times with someone I knew. JR handed me a harp to try out once and I played it. No big deal.

But, the drunk that grabbed a harp from my case on stage and put it in his mouth? That one got seriously sanitized before I touched it again :-)


----------
Jim McBride
Bottle 'O Blues microphones
www.bottleoblues.com
The Iceman
3265 posts
Jul 19, 2017
5:31 PM
Usually a big NO, but there are always extenuating circumstances.

One time in the 90's, Mark Hummel was playing at a bar-b-que club in Royal Oak, MI, down the street from where I was living. He had a problem with one harmonica and during the break asked if he could borrow one of mine for the last set. I said ok. Now, Mark uses much more force than I and actually stressed it out pretty badly to the point that I had to retune it later. I figured it went with the territory of helping a friend out at a gig. I wouldn't have let him borrow a custom harmonica, but one of my stock ones - no problem.
----------
The Iceman
BronzeWailer
2001 posts
Jul 19, 2017
6:11 PM
I was busking one day when Christelle happened by and I lent her one of mine because she didn't have one on her. Neither of us suffered ill effects to my knowledge.
BronzeWailer's YouTube
florida-trader
1167 posts
Jul 19, 2017
8:01 PM
At SPAH (and other harmonica workshop gatherings) it is very common to try harps that are not yours. First, there are the demo harps at all the major manufcturers. Hohner, Seydel and Suzuki have always had demo harps you can play and the new kids on the block - the two Chinese companies that were at SPAH last year had demo harps too. There is always an abundance of alcohol wipes and/or antibacterial spray available with which to clean them prior to and after using them.

At the Blue Moon Booth, you are welcome to take any of my harps for a test drive. Some people politely decline but most dive right in. It is likely the one place where you can try before you buy. You can't do that at Sam Ash or Guitar Center or if you buy online.

Lastly, there are lots of guys who tweak/customize their harps and they are eager to show off their work. It might be a "Hey, look at me" type of thing or it could be in the interest of getting constructive feedback. Either way it amounts to the same thing - letting other people play your harps.

But I'm not sure if this qualifies as "Sharing harps" Maybe I'm splitting hairs but there is a difference between playing a harp for a minute or two and borrowing a harp(s) for a gig.
----------
Tom Halchak
www.BlueMoonHarmonicas.com
 photo BMH Banner resized for email signature_zpseilpcgeo.jpg

Last Edited by florida-trader on Jul 19, 2017 8:04 PM
groyster1
2969 posts
Jul 20, 2017
8:48 AM
you could share with someone who has active TB....not worth taking that chance.....I play only my harps with my germs....others can do the same
Martin
1201 posts
Jul 20, 2017
8:54 AM
Let´s say under the right circumstances a strange but seriously interesting woman has caught your interest, and you have hers. The a bit later on in the evening, do you say, "Sorry honey, I don´t kiss -- unless you thoroughly disinfect your oral cavities first"?
How utterly romantic.
Littoral
1503 posts
Jul 20, 2017
10:13 AM
Tom, I haven't been to SPAH so your experience is enlightening. I guess it's true, you have to play them to know.
shakeylee
677 posts
Jul 20, 2017
11:51 AM
Like TMF714 above,I certainly have with james cotton. Somebody like that asks to use your harp,you say "yes."

I did almost die once from it. An important Philadelphia harmonica player,who is no longer with us ,shared my harp. I got tonsillitis . Then,the antibiotic I went on first didn't work and my throats closed up so much so,that I couldn't breathe.
However,after that,I went on penicillin and it cleared up.

I still do share harps with some women though. Pretty much,if I would make out with her,she can use my harp . :)
----------
www.shakeylee.com
Irish Soul
38 posts
Jul 20, 2017
4:58 PM
I think it's all personal preference....if I'd share a canteen with you or if you were a woman I'd (well you know)...I would likely toss you my harp.

But...if you are a drunk I don't know and grab my harp off a stage we are likely both going to jail.

Truly there is no right or wrong, just what you can live with on this one, in my opinion.

Health hazard? Maybe. So is crossing the street, smoking, drinking, sex and many other things.


Post a Message



(8192 Characters Left)


Modern Blues Harmonica supports

§The Jazz Foundation of America

and

§The Innocence Project

 

 

 

ADAM GUSSOW is an official endorser for HOHNER HARMONICAS