Header Graphic
Dirty-South Blues Harp forum: wail on! > which among three positions
which among three positions
Login  |  Register
Page: 1

mikolune
99 posts
Feb 15, 2012
8:15 AM
Hi,

I found this JJ Milteau video and was trying to work on it. It seems 3 harp keys fit very well and I am wondering which key it is he is actually using in his first solo.

I could play it on an E (2st pos?), A (3rd pos?) and a B (1st pos?) I would think he is playing either in 3rd or first pos due to some of the bends I can hear, but I am not sure. We also see him changing harps at some point.

Or am I completely wrong with the position ?

cheers!

timeistight
334 posts
Feb 15, 2012
9:14 AM
It's in E so your E harp would be 1st, A would be 2nd and B would be 12th.
Tuckster
967 posts
Feb 15, 2012
9:17 AM

Last Edited by on Feb 15, 2012 9:18 AM
mikolune
100 posts
Feb 15, 2012
9:41 AM
Thx timeistight!
tmf714
1000 posts
Feb 15, 2012
10:50 AM
Sounds good in third with a D harp as well-
mikolune
101 posts
Feb 15, 2012
1:32 PM
Wondering which of these positions he's playing.

Also, would you call this a blues ? It's got the spirit, but technically it isn't a twelve bar - has only 2 chords as far as tabs on the net seem to say.
tmf714
1001 posts
Feb 15, 2012
2:08 PM
Sounds like 1st position for the beginning-E harp-then second postion-A harp-on the break.
dougharps
163 posts
Feb 15, 2012
2:15 PM
This is sort of a folk/country/blues style, not straight blues. I messed around with it a little in 2nd, 1st, 3rd, and 12th position. My initial opinion is that all but 3rd could be used effectively without overblows, but none seemed to fit what he was doing exactly as regards bent notes.

Possibly some alternate tuning like circular tuning?

If I figure it out, I will post again.

Captcha... repost
----------



Doug S.
harpwrench
572 posts
Feb 15, 2012
2:48 PM
I think he's using a B harp in 12th to start out with...

----------
Spiers Harmonicas
tmf714
1002 posts
Feb 15, 2012
3:16 PM
JJ does use Harmonic and Natural Minor tunings-
dougharps
164 posts
Feb 15, 2012
3:39 PM
@harpwrench
You might be correct. The range of the pitches in his solo certainly fits with B harp in 12th, and at first I thought it was B in 12th (A in second would be an octave lower for what he was doing, and the pattern did not seem like 1st on E to me). But I thought I heard a bend that was inconsistent with B in 12th. I will have to listen again and work on it some more later to see if I was right about the bent note.

Captcha... try again
----------



Doug S.
mikolune
102 posts
Feb 15, 2012
6:19 PM
thanks for input! I am becoming a bigger fan of 12th every day.
WinslowYerxa
183 posts
Feb 15, 2012
8:24 PM
It's a high A harp in second position starting about 0:35. Everything he's doing fits exactly second position, just an octave higher
dougharps
166 posts
Feb 16, 2012
8:56 AM
Thanks, Winslow. A high A harp had passed though my mind as a possibility due to how it sounded on the regular A, but I wanted to rule out B in 12th. I guess I did hear an inconsistent bend, as I thought.
----------



Doug S.


Post a Message



(8192 Characters Left)


Modern Blues Harmonica supports

§The Jazz Foundation of America

and

§The Innocence Project

 

 

 

ADAM GUSSOW is an official endorser for HOHNER HARMONICAS