Header Graphic
Dirty-South Blues Harp forum: wail on! > Harpboxing with a bass?
Harpboxing with a bass?
Login  |  Register
Page: 1

10BIT
32 posts
May 02, 2015
5:24 AM
Hello!
I have been working hard at improving my harpboxing and came to a screeching halt lately as i could not find anything new to incorporate into my playing
so i tried out playiung the bass while i harpbox!

I feel like it can sound really nice if i practice but i am uncertain if i should do that...
Id love to hear your opinions about this

In the following video i pretty much tried this concept for the first time and thus it sounds weird at times
Ill have to figure out what sounds best and in what speed i should play it but i think it doesnt sound too bad

I'd appreciate feedback!

Disclaimer:
it gets better after the first few seconds^^

nacoran
8469 posts
May 02, 2015
12:19 PM
There are parts that work, but as a whole, you've got to work piece you've got to work on keeping your timing more consistent. You also need to work on developing strong opinions about what is working for yourself- what I mean is you post a lot of experiments, which is fine, but take the time to do a take where you get the parts you know don't work out of it first- not because we won't patiently sit through it, but because it's really important to develop that internal voice that lets you know when it's working or not, and some of that means doing some self-critique. It also makes it hard to critique your work because we have to point out the parts that obviously aren't working and can't spend as much focus on more subtle tips on the parts that are.

Looking at your setup, get yourself a boom mic if you are going to hold the harp in your hands, or use a harp rack if you aren't. I think you are handicapping yourself by using the mic hanging from your neck- it looks like it's getting in your way but it's still not giving you two free hands. Another solution, some keyboards let you program in a tune pretty quickly. You could do that, or use a loop pedal, to record the bass part and then focus on the harpboxing. Guys like Son of Dave use their loop pedal and some of those cheap shaker eggs to build up their rhythms on top of what they are doing with their mouths. The trick there is you have to sort of compose/arrange the toon in your head beforehand so that you can hit all the right cues for the toon.

As to the simplest part of the question, I think the bass works well with the harpboxing (although there are pure beatboxers who can produce those notes vocally).



----------
Nate
Facebook
Thread Organizer (A list of all sorts of useful threads)

First Post- May 8, 2009
10BIT
33 posts
May 02, 2015
12:52 PM
Hey!
thanks for your tips
self critique has always been a problem of mine :/

I guess a loop pedal cant hurt
will definately look into it

I'm still a beginner at the whole music thing
started with the harp as my first instrument about a year ago and I cant afford professional training sadly
I should really look into producing bass with my mouth :D

thanks again for your comment!


Post a Message



(8192 Characters Left)


Modern Blues Harmonica supports

§The Jazz Foundation of America

and

§The Innocence Project

 

 

 

ADAM GUSSOW is an official endorser for HOHNER HARMONICAS